HNA Holding: 50B Valuation, Share Price Drops to 1

The financial landscape of China's stock market is characterized by its volatility and rapid shifts, particularly in segments dominated by low-priced stocks. Such has been the case with Hainan Airlines Holding Co., Ltd., trading under the stock code 600221.SH. Over recent weeks, the company has succumbed to a prolonged descent in stock price, nearing the psychological threshold of 1 yuan per share—a situation that could potentially trigger delisting due to Chinese regulations around face value.

On June 26, a mere half an hour into trading, Hainan Airlines hit its daily trading limit down, reporting an intraday low of 1.05 yuan before closing slightly higher at 1.11 yuan. The company experienced significantly heightened trading volume, amounting to approximately 5.62 billion yuan, yet the market capitalization dwindled to around 480 billion yuan. This alarming decline has sparked worries among investors about the substantial risk of face value delisting—a scenario that can occur for stocks dipping below the minimum threshold deemed viable by regulators.

Advertisement

In the realm of publicly traded companies, many that have experienced delisting due to falling below their nominal value typically have dwindled market capitalizations, often in the range of several billion yuan. Such firms frequently struggle with maintaining operational viability or profitability over time. In stark contrast, Hainan Airlines possesses a market cap nearing 500 billion yuan, illustrating a considerable cushion against such a dire outcome. Moreover, the firm achieved a remarkable turnaround during the first quarter of this year, reporting profits when many others in the market languished in losses.

Despite such favorable fundamentals, sentiment regarding lower-priced stocks has spiraled into pessimism, making it increasingly difficult for companies like Hainan Airlines, with solid operational foundations, to escape the downdraft. Feedback from industry analysts suggests that this selling frenzy is exacerbated by the prevailing macroeconomic environment and fluctuations across major Chinese indices, which contribute to the general malaise affecting investor sentiment towards low-tier stocks.

On the same day that Hainan Airlines continued its downward spiral, the broader A-share market rallied as the key indices staged a recovery. However, this positive momentum did not extend to Hainan—its stock continued to suffer, with losses persisting throughout much of the trading day. The trends became particularly clear beginning from late May when the stock began an unrelenting slide. By June 5, the stock had fallen to 1.31 yuan, breaking through a support level established over half a year, subsequently leading to a further decline of around 18.38% over the month, with a notable near 9% dip in just the last three days.

When evaluated against its peers within the aviation sector, Hainan Airlines' stock performance has lagged significantly since the onset of the second quarter. Among eight major airline stocks, Hainan stood at the bottom, with a staggering 18.98% decrease since April, while others like Huaxia Airlines surged, demonstrating gains of over 23% during the same period. The growing gap exemplifies the distinct challenges facing Hainan in reversing investor sentiment and building market confidence.

As the month progressed, the situation grew increasingly tenuous, with the company approaching record low prices not seen since June 2006. A further 11% dip from the current figures could plunge the stock below the critical 1 yuan threshold. Recently, the company sought to assure investors regarding the risks associated with its declining stock price. In responses provided on investor platforms, they highlighted the multidimensional factors influencing stock prices, including macroeconomic trends and shifts in investor behavior, thus affirming a commitment to stabilizing its market value through strategic measures.

Analysts opine that the continuous slump in share price is attributed to a confluence of factors. An intensified drive toward eliminating underperforming assets has reshaped the investing landscape, yielding a vicious cycle where lower-priced stocks gradually attract less buying interest, further fuelling their decline. This trend manifests starkly within the low-priced stock category, where investors increasingly shy away from acquiring shares as prices dip closer to the 1 yuan mark. Specific data from Wind illustrates that since mid-June, stocks trading below 1.5 yuan on the Shanghai and Shenzhen exchanges have experienced average declines of around 9.15%, indicating systemic instability in low-tier stock valuations.

Additionally, with the A-share market undergoing a string of adjustments, combined with the seasonal pressures typical in the second quarter, the aviation sector has faced profound challenges, leading to aggressive selloffs as the uncertainties surrounding interim performances weigh on investor confidence.

Notably, since June, significant sell-offs from the Shanghai Stock Connect indicate that institutional investors are reconsidering their positions in Hainan Airlines. Figures reveal a drastic reduction in holdings from 672 million shares down to 532 million, reflecting growing unease with the company's outlook amidst prevailing market dynamics.

In light of a troubled second quarter, Hainan Airlines has acknowledged its operational pressures candidly. While IPO trends suggest companies that converse with poor governance and insolvency face the risks of being delisted, Hainan proponents argue their fundamentals remain sound, indicating potential for future recovery. The Q1 2023 report displayed remarkable growth, with revenues jumping by 33.48% year-on-year and net profits soaring over 334%. Yet, despite this encouraging beginning to the fiscal year, market conditions, seasonal fluctuations, and heightened competition have conspired against Hainan in the second quarter, resulting in noticeable declines in passenger transport volume.

Recent figures reveal that during May, the airline faced a month-over-month drop in passenger traffic of 1.27%, despite a year-on-year increase. Concurrently, capacity deployment witnessed a modest decrease, highlighting the ongoing pressure within the commercial aviation segment. These performance metrics underscore the steep uphill battle confronted by Hainan Airlines as it seeks to navigate a renewed focus on operational efficiency amidst an uncertain market landscape.

During institutional research discussions, executives from Hainan have expressed expectations for a robust recovery in the summer air travel market, anticipating heightened demand from popular tourism destinations. However, challenges remain with international routes experiencing diversified recoveries influenced by geopolitical dynamics and existing competitive pressures. In delineating the contours of future growth, Hainan Airlines posits an optimistic forecasting of aligning their international capacity to pre-pandemic levels by the end of 2024, even as they brace for the complexities accompanying an intensely competitive market environment.